Call us (06)505-2916 . FAX(06)-5052917

2014南區英文辯論比賽

國立鳳山高級中學「2014南區英文辯論比賽」實施計畫

一、背景分析:

台灣北區已有多年為高中生辦理英文辯論比賽的歷史,中區也從去年開始舉辦高中英文辯論比賽,成為台灣中北部各高中優秀學生爭取參與的年度盛事,唯獨南區從未舉辦過類似的比賽目前台灣師範大學英語系極力爭取由教育部辦理全國高中生英文辯論比賽,藉以提升學生英文思辯能力屆時,若是南區仍未有類似比賽,南部優秀高中生將在這場盛會中缺席,實屬可惜因此希望透過本校主辦第一屆南區高中生英文辯論比賽,讓比賽優勝隊伍代表南區高中參加全國英文辯論比賽。國立鳳山高中是高雄歷史悠久的優良學府,致力於發展人文與科技並重的「學術型學校」,除了紮實的高中基礎學科教育之外,更希望透過各種學術活動的交流,提供學生更多元的學習方式。有鑑於台灣高中生在考試壓力下普遍欠缺獨立思辨能力、英語學習也侷限於考試導向,無法提升學習的廣度及深度,2013年本校首次針對高雄地區高中師生辦理「英文辯論及批判思考研習營」活動,由本校、高雄女中、高師大附中、鳳新高中英文教師及學生共同參與,學生反應熱烈,活動深獲參與師生及旁聽之家長好評。藉由辦理英文辯論比賽,有效訓練學生批判思考能力,督促學生關心社會議題,提升英語口語表達及書寫能力,並提供學生與他校學生切磋交流的平台,延續學生不斷精進的動力,相信這樣的成效是教育單位及家長所樂見的。

二、計畫目的:

() 提升學生英文表達能力,深化英文學習層次

() 養成學生主動關心時事,並深入研究議題的能力。

() 藉由校際英文辯論比賽,增加各校優秀學生相互學習的機會。

三、辦理單位:國立鳳山高級中學教務處及英文科

四、辦理日期:103419(星期六)

五、辦理地點:鳳山高中三樓會議室及一般教室

六、參與對象:高雄、屏東及台南區高中生共12

七、報名方式: 請各校在103320日前將報名表傳真或寄至鳳山高中以報名優先順序為原則
  
最多錄取12每隊3參賽學生頒發參賽證明,優勝隊伍及最佳辯士另外頒發獎狀。

八、辯題:That the Taiwan government should make public sex offenders’ personal information.

報名時間及方式:102317()320()下午17時止。將報名表傳真至學務處活
   
動組洪滿江老師收傳真號碼:(07) 743-9148。請於傳真後與學務處以電話確認, 電話: (07)
    7463150#360
洪滿江老師

比賽時間及地點:

時間:102419()下午1310分始。

地點:國立鳳山高級中學(高雄市鳳山區光復路二段130號)

 


2014南區英語辯論比賽」實施規則

一.     辯題

That the Taiwan government should make public sex offenders’ personal information.

二.     比賽規則說明

(一)  比賽地點:國立鳳山高級中學。。

(二)  比賽時間:2014419()下午1310分開始報到、1330分賽前說明、1410分開始比賽,遲到之隊伍視為棄權。

本辯論比賽採以下方式:每場比賽由正方一隊,反方一隊參加,每隊三人,時間三十五分鐘,兩方依申論先後順序,分為正方一辯、二辯、交叉質詢、結辯與反方一辯、二辯、交叉質詢、結辯,六位辯士上台順序與辯論時間如下:

1.          正方一辯申論四分鐘

2.         正方一辯接受反方二辯交叉質詢二分鐘

3.          反方一辯申論四分鐘

4.         反方一辯接受正方一辯交叉質詢二分鐘

5.          正方二辯申論四分鐘

6.         正方二辯接受反方一辯交叉質詢二分鐘

7.          反方二辯申論四分鐘

8.         反方二辯接受正方二辯交叉質詢二分鐘

9.         準備時間五分鐘

10.     反方三辯結辯三分鐘

11.      正方三辯結辯三分鐘

若參賽隊伍未依照以上辯論順序進行, 該部分將不予以計分。

(三)  場次及正反方:2014327()由主辦單位抽籤決定初賽各場次及正反方。複賽之場次及正反方於初賽後抽籤決定。

(四)  裁判:每場比賽有三位裁判,將聘請大學教授及高中老師或有相關背景之社會人士擔任評審。初賽及複賽每場比賽由三位評審評分。

(五)  進行方式:

比賽採單淘汰制,取前二強。若參賽隊伍所構成之場次為偶數,則經初、複賽後產生優勝隊伍;若參賽隊伍所構成之場次為奇數,則以抽籤方式選出一種子隊,待他隊進行初賽後,種子隊再加入複賽。第一輪的初選賽獲勝隊伍,於第二輪的總決賽爭取「優勝隊伍」及「最佳辯士」的榮譽。第二輪的敗部賽,由初賽的失敗隊伍參加。第一輪敗北但第二輪獲勝以及第一輪獲勝但第二輪敗北的隊伍則可爭取「優良辯士」的頭銜。

(六)  辯論時,禁止使用視覺輔助道具。

(七)  各隊應準備Evidence Cards,以備裁判審查佐證資料(整場辯論之後,做出勝負判決之前)之用。

(八)  計時方式:辯論當中計時員將舉牌,顯示剩下時間。申論時,計時牌分別顯示剩下二分鐘、一分鐘及半分鐘。質詢時,計時牌分別顯示剩下一分鐘及半分鐘。結辯時,計時牌分別顯示剩下二分鐘、一分鐘及半分鐘。時間到時,計時員將響鈴,之後每十秒鐘響鈴一次,一超過三十秒即強迫下台,超過時間,每十秒鐘扣總分一分。輪到任何一隊做申論、質詢或結辯時,計時員將響鈴,鈴響後該隊應立即上台,若不按時間出場,每晚十秒鐘扣總分一分

(九)  攜帶物品:學生請務必攜帶身份證或學生證。辯論時可攜帶字典及資料。

三.     比賽場地注意事項

(一)  場地內沒有麥克風。

(二)  教室內不得飲食,請勿攜帶食物入內。

(三)  比賽開始後將關閉後門,除主辯單位的工作人員外,禁止任何人出入。

(四)  為避免影響辯論同學,比賽開始後請勿走動或交談,並請確實關手機。

(五)  比賽進行中請勿鼓掌喧鬧。

(六)  若欲錄影請於賽前架設完畢,欲照相者切勿使用閃光燈,以免打擾比賽之進行。

(七)  競賽場地待安排確認後,再行通知各參賽學校。

四.     比賽當日注意事項

學生請穿著制服以外的整齊服裝,於報到時請學生出示身份證或學生證。


The First Southern Taiwan English Debate Tournament Activity Rules

1.       Resolved:

That the Taiwan government should make public sex offenders’ personal information.

2.      Rules:

(1)        Place: National Experimental High School at Central Taiwan Science Park

(2)       Time: Sign in at 13:10 on April 19th (Sat.) 2014, Rules Explained at 13:30, and Debate starts at 14:10. The one that is late will be eliminated.

(3)        The outline of the debate is as follows:

For the senior high

[A]      First Affirmative constructive speech 4 minutes

[B]       Second Negative cross examines First Affirmative 2 minutes

[C]       First Negative constructive speech 4 minutes

[D]      First Affirmative cross examines First Negative 2 minutes

[E]       Second Affirmative constructive speech 4 minutes

[F]       First Negative cross examines Second Affirmative 2 minutes

[G]      Second Negative constructive speech 4 minutes

[H]      Second Affirmative cross examines Second Negative 2 minutes

[I]         Preparation period for rebuttal speech 5 minutes

[J]        Third Negative Rebuttal 3 minutes

[K]      Third Affirmative Rebuttal 3 minutes

If any team doesn’t follow the sequence of the debate above, then the grade of this part won’t be calculated.

(4)       On March 27st (Mon.) 2014, the host will draw “Affirmative” or “Negative” for each school. (You can send one person to come on that day) For the second round, we will draw “Affirmative” or “Negative” on April. 19th (Sat.) following the first round.

(5)        Judges: Each competition will have 3 judges. We will invite professors and senior high school teachers to be judges.

(6)       Grading Criteria

[A]      In each competition of the first and second round, there will be 3 judges. All the judges are assigned by the host. Judges will not be scoring their own school.

[B]       For the judging criteria, please refer to the judging sheet.

[C]       Judging standard: If the total points are 10, give 9-10 for an excellent performance; 7-8 for a great performance; 5-6 for a good performance; 3-4 for an ordinary performance; 1-2 for a weaker performance.

[D]      If the total points are 5, give 5 for an excellent performance; 4 for a great performance; 3 for a good performance; 2 for an ordinary performance; 1 for a weaker performance. Judges should make a clear resolution without giving the same score to both of the teams.

[E]       Judges can give a 0.5 point to each grading category.

[F]       The total score of a team is based on the teamwork.

(7)        Procedure:

There will be 12 teams for total. Each team will have three debaters or more. A single knock-out system will be adopted to all the competitions. Only the first and the second prizes will be given. If the number of the teams is even, there will be a first and a second round to compete for the prizes. If the number is odd, a seeded team will be determined through drawing lots. The seeded team will join the second round after the first round is completed.

(8)       To encourage the participants, the losing teams of the first round will join a second round of losing teams to gain the honor of the Honorable Mention Debater. Meanwhile, the winning teams of the first round will also join a second round of winning teams to gain the honor of the Best Debate Team or the honor of the Best Debater.

(9)       Each team needs to prepare evidence cards for judges’ random examination (after the debate and before the winner is announced).

(10)    Debaters must bring their Student ID cards or ID cards. Also, they are allowed to bring dictionaries and information.

(11)    No visual aids allowed during the debates (e.g. posters or charts).

(12)    Students must wear uniforms.

3.       Attention:

(1)        Inside the classroom, there will be no microphone.

(2)       Eating and drinking are not allowed in the classroom.

(3)        We will close the door right after the competition begins. Nobody is admitted except for our coordinators.

(4)       In order not to disturb debaters, chatting and walking around the classroom are not allowed during the debate. Also, please make sure to turn off your cell-phone as well.

(5)        No clapping during the debate.

(6)       If you want to record, please set up the machine before it begins. Also, do not use a flash when you are taking photos.

(7)        Debate classrooms will be assigned to each school team after confirmation.

4.      Each school will have one team first. If you want to have a second team, you will have to wait until each school signs up.

5.       Each school needs to assign one English teacher to judge.

6.      If you have any question, please feel free to contact with Miss Hung (07) 7463150 # 360

7.       Schedule:

Step

Time

Event

Place

1

March 17th to March 20 th

 

Sign up

By fax (07)743-9148

2

March 21st

 

Inform each school if they have a second team in

By e-mail

3

March 26th  

Final list of final debaters (cannot be changed after the date)

By fax (07)743-9148

4

March 27th

16:30 ~ 17:00

Draw “Affirmative” or “Negative”

At Principal’s Office of FSSH

5

April 19th

13:10~ 17:00

The First Sothern Taiwan English Debate Tournament

On the campus of FSSH


2014南區英語辯論比賽報名表

學校名稱:_________________________

學校簡稱_________________________ (請書寫六字學校簡稱,以利獎狀印刷)

報名第一隊

          指導教師:______________________

          電話:(O) ____________________ (手機) ______________________

          E-mail____________________________________

          學生辯士1_________ 中英文姓名:_____________________ (1)

          學生辯士2_________ 中英文姓名:_____________________ (2)

學生辯士3_________ 中英文姓名:_____________________ (結辯)

學生辯士1_________ 中英文姓名:_____________________

學生辯士2_________ 中英文姓名:_____________________

報名第二隊

          指導教師:______________________

          電話:(O) ____________________ (手機) ______________________

          E-mail____________________________________

          學生辯士1_________ 中英文姓名:_____________________ (1)

          學生辯士2_________ 中英文姓名:_____________________ (2)

學生辯士3_________ 中英文姓名:_____________________ (結辯)

學生辯士1_________ 中英文姓名:_____________________

學生辯士2_________ 中英文姓名:_____________________

儲備評審教師_____________________

電話:(O) ____________________ (手機) ______________________

E-mail____________________________________

 

聯絡人______________________

電話:(O) ____________________ (手機) ______________________

E-mail____________________________________

 

1. 請於2014320日下午17時前傳真(07)743-9148傳真後請與學務處社團活動組洪滿江老師(07)746-3150#360以電話確認。

2. 若學生姓名尚未確定,請先報名,並請於326前補送學生辯士名單。

3. 將於2014321通知是否錄取同校第二隊。

4. 請務必以清楚字體寫明中英文姓名,俾以獎狀製作。

 

校長                  教務主任                   承辦人

(簽章)                  (簽章)                     (簽章)


當日活動流程

時間

事項

13:10 – 13:20

各校報到

13:30 – 14:00

開幕典禮及賽前說明

14:10 – 15:10

第一回合比賽

15:10 – 15:15

第二回合抽籤

15:45 – 16:45

第二回合比賽

16:45 – 17:00

綜合講評及閉幕典禮